Why Do Softball Players Throw Underhand?

Softball, a dynamic and thrilling sport derived from baseball, has captivated audiences around the world with its unique blend of strategy, skill, and athleticism. The underhand pitch, delivered in a graceful and circular motion, is a hallmark of the sport, contributing to its distinct identity. 

In the world of softball, where strategy meets athleticism, the underhand pitch emerges as a captivating dance on the diamond. The throw underhand, a graceful and strategic move, becomes the focal point of this captivating performance. Join us as we step into the field, where the underhand pitch weaves its magic, challenging batters and adding an enchanting layer to the symphony of softball.

Unlike baseball, where pitchers employ an overhand delivery, softball pitchers deliver the ball in an underhand motion. In this exploration, we delve into the historical evolution, biomechanics, and strategic nuances of the underhand pitch in softball, seeking to understand not only why players choose this technique but also how it shapes the very essence of the game.

Historical Evolution of Underhand Pitching

To understand why softball players throw underhand, it is crucial to delve into the historical evolution of the sport. Softball originated in the late 19th century as an indoor version of baseball, primarily played by women. 

The close-quarters environment of indoor facilities necessitated a modified pitching style, leading to the adoption of the underhand pitch. Over time, as the sport transitioned outdoors and gained recognition, the underhand pitch became a defining characteristic of softball.

Biomechanics of Underhand Pitching

The biomechanics of underhand pitching in softball play a pivotal role in its adoption by softball players. Unlike baseball pitchers who rely on overhand throwing, softball pitchers employ a windmill motion characterized by a circular arm movement. 

This windmill motion allows for a smoother, more controlled release of the ball, reducing the stress on the pitcher’s arm and shoulder. The underhand delivery in softball is biomechanically advantageous, promoting efficiency and minimizing the risk of injuries associated with overhand throwing.

Strategic Advantages of Underhand Pitching

The underhand pitch in softball offers strategic advantages that contribute significantly to the game’s dynamics. The angle of the pitch and its trajectory create unique challenges for batters. The underhand delivery often results in a higher release point, making it more challenging for batters to judge the pitch’s speed and location.

The Psychological Element

Beyond its biomechanical and strategic aspects, the underhand pitch in softball introduces a psychological element to the game. Batters accustomed to facing overhand pitches in baseball may find the underhand delivery disorienting. 

The unfamiliarity with the windmill motion, coupled with the inherent difficulty in tracking the ball’s path, can create a mental challenge for batters. Softball pitchers leverage this psychological aspect to gain a competitive edge, adding an extra layer of complexity to the game.

Pitching Techniques and Styles

Within the realm of underhand pitching, various techniques and styles have emerged, contributing to the diversity and richness of the sport. The most common underhand pitch in softball is the fastpitch, characterized by high velocity and spin. The windmill motion allows pitchers to generate significant speed, challenging batters to react swiftly. 

In contrast, slowpitch softball features a more deliberate underhand pitch, emphasizing accuracy and placement over sheer speed. The range of pitching techniques accommodates different player preferences and strategic approaches, enhancing the strategic depth of the game.

Influence of Rule Variations

Influence of Rule Variations

The underhand pitch in softball is not solely defined by its biomechanics and strategy; rule variations also shape its prominence in the sport. Softball organizations and leagues may implement specific rules governing pitching styles, mound distances, and other factors that directly impact the underhand delivery. 

Understanding these rule variations is essential for players and coaches seeking to optimize their approach to underhand pitching within the context of specific leagues and competitions.

Training and Development

The adoption of the underhand pitch in softball necessitates specialized training and development programs. Pitchers must hone their windmill motion, focusing on mechanics, strength, and flexibility to maximize performance and minimize the risk of injuries. Coaches play a crucial role in guiding pitchers through the nuances of underhand pitching, emphasizing the importance of consistency, control, and adaptability. 

As softball continues to evolve, advancements in training techniques and technology contribute to the ongoing refinement of underhand pitching skills.

Injury Prevention and Longevity

One of the primary reasons softball players throw underhand is the emphasis on injury prevention and player longevity. The biomechanics of the underhand pitch, particularly the circular motion of the windmill delivery, places less strain on the pitcher’s arm and shoulder compared to the overhand motion in baseball. 

As a result, softball pitchers experience lower rates of shoulder and elbow injuries, promoting a more sustainable and extended playing career. The underhand pitch aligns with the broader trend in sports toward prioritizing player health and reducing the risk of overuse injuries.

The Evolution of Softball Strategy

The underhand pitch has not remained static throughout the history of softball. As the sport evolves, so too do the strategies employed by pitchers and teams. Changes in equipment, playing surfaces, and player athleticism contribute to the dynamic nature of softball strategy.

Pitchers continually seek innovative ways to enhance the effectiveness of their underhand delivery, whether through variations in spin, speed, or deception. Analyzing the evolution of softball strategy provides insights into the adaptability and creativity inherent in the sport.

Gender Dynamics in Softball

The underhand pitch in softball is closely tied to the historical roots of the sport as a women’s game. While softball is now played by both men and women at various levels, the underhand pitch remains a defining characteristic of the women’s game. 

The gender dynamics in softball, including differences in pitching distance, ball size, and playing field dimensions, contribute to the distinctiveness of the underhand pitch. Understanding the interplay between gender dynamics and pitching styles adds a sociocultural dimension to the broader narrative of softball.

Comparative Analysis with Baseball

A comprehensive exploration of why softball players throw underhand would be incomplete without a comparative analysis with baseball. While both sports share common origins, they have evolved into distinct entities with unique playing styles. 

Here’s a comparative analysis table highlighting key differences between softball and baseball:

Pitching StyleUnderhand (windmill motion)Overhand (various pitching styles, e.g., fastball, curveball)
Pitching DistanceShorter distance (typically 43 feet for women, 46 feet for men)Longer distance (60 feet 6 inches)
Pitcher’s MoundCircular or diamond-shaped moundRaised, rectangular mound
Ball SizeLarger, with a circumference of 11 or 12 inchesSmaller, with a circumference of 9 inches
Game DurationTypically shorter gamesLonger games with more innings
Field DimensionsSmaller infield and outfieldLarger infield and outfield
Base DistancesShorter base paths (60 feet)Longer base paths (90 feet)
ScoringOften higher-scoring gamesLower-scoring games
Lead-offs and StealingLimited or no lead-offs; stealing may be restrictedLead-offs allowed; stealing is common
StrategyEmphasis on quick reactions, speed, and agilityStrategic plays, varied pitching strategies
Gender DynamicsHistorically associated with women’s sports, but played by both gendersTraditionally a male-dominated sport, with women’s leagues emerging

This table provides a concise overview of key distinctions between softball and baseball, encompassing pitching styles, field dimensions, game dynamics, and other relevant aspects.

Challenges and Controversies

Despite its many advantages, the underhand pitch in softball is not without challenges and controversies. Critics argue that the underhand delivery places an excessive burden on the batter, limiting offensive opportunities. 

Others contend that the underhand pitch lacks the spectacle and excitement associated with the high-velocity overhand pitches seen in baseball. Addressing these challenges requires a balanced perspective that considers the interests of both pitchers and batters, as well as the broader fan base.


What’s the historical reason for underhand pitching in softball?

Softball players throw underhand as it originates from the sport’s indoor baseball roots, adapting to smaller spaces and promoting inclusivity.

How does underhand pitching benefit softball players?

Underhand pitching in softball offers better control, accuracy, and allows for strategic variations, giving pitchers a nuanced advantage over their opponents.

Are there specific rules in softball that dictate underhand pitching?

Yes, softball rules mandate underhand pitching, emphasizing the sport’s unique characteristics and differentiating it from overhand pitching in baseball.


In conclusion, throw underhand in softball is a multifaceted aspect of the sport that encompasses historical, biomechanical, strategic, and cultural dimensions. From its origins as an indoor game for women to its current status as a global sport played by men and women alike, softball’s underhand pitch has endured and evolved. The biomechanical advantages, strategic intricacies, and psychological elements associated with the underhand delivery contribute to its enduring appeal.

As softball continues to evolve, the underhand pitch will likely remain a cornerstone of the sport, defining its identity and shaping the experiences of players and fans alike. The ongoing interplay between tradition and innovation, coupled with a commitment to player health and longevity, ensures that the underhand pitch in softball will continue to be a dynamic and integral element of this beloved sport.

Leave a Comment